Telltale’s latest foray into the world of The Walking Dead has come to an end thanks to the finale episode for the “A New Frontier” plot thread. The episode itself lacked a bit of gut punches, especially when you compare them to the finales of other Telltale TWD games, but it still provided a nice conclusion to the narrative while setting up future series. You can check out the full review below in video form. If you prefer to read the script has been embedded after the video.

Hey now gamers, Matt Heywood here to review the final episode of Telltale’s latest foray into The Walking Dead franchise via the A New Frontier storyline, which is titled From the Gallows.

Spoilers may be present from past episodes, but the major plot points from the finale will not be spoiled in this review.

From the Gallows, like the previous four episodes, opens with a Flashback to flesh out the rocky relationship between Javi and his angry big bro David. Like the other flashbacks it serves as a history lesson on the less than brotherly relationship Javi and David have, as well as little plot moments that foreshadow events to come in the current episode.

Once the flashback rolls you’re right back to the action, or should I say shit show you left behind at the end of episode 4. There really isn’t much time to dilly dally as you’re thrust right into the thick of things and get right to Telltale’s patented QTE gameplay system for its narrative heavy games. I did like getting involved in action heavy sequences early on, because it kept me engaged with the plot and stepped up the peril meter for Javi and his gang.

After the dust settles you are presented with a few major plot decisions that can affect how your experience in this episode plays out. Let’s just say the first major decision will play on your morals, as you must decide the future direction of Javi and his group. The decision is pretty black and white, but making the choice isn’t easy as it can severely impact those around you, as well as the Richmond settlement that has become a walker circus thanks to the end of episode 4.

Regardless of the decision you make you set off with the gang, at least those you’ve kept alive, and try to right a few wrongs with David, as well as Richmond itself. The meat of the narrative though swings back to Javi and David, and how they’re relationship in the past has impacted the future. These two are at odds over a plethora of reasons, and most of your final game changing decisions revolve around how you see the bond between these brothers. If you have found David to be a dick, things can get easy in the decision department, but if you’re trying to play a Saintly Javi and save David from himself, your choices can get a bit muddier.

Either way you will be forced to make a major decision like the other Clementine starring telltale series, which will definitely lead to the deaths of a few of the main characters.

While the choices in this episode were dire, I never really felt any anxiety in making them, or a feeling of loss or joy. Something just didn’t resonate with me in a narrative sense, so while this episode can fork in so many ways in terms of its plot, I never felt stressed about making a decision that would more than likely kill a main character. Maybe the results seemed just too obvious to me, but I was hoping to feel a bit more emotional towards the characters and where I was driving them, but that just wasn’t the case.

From the Gallows just felt like a weak finale overall, but it at least concludes in a way where we know more The Walking Dead action will be coming from Telltale. That’s a good thing, because while A New Frontier missed a few beats here and there, it still is a fine entry in The Walking Dead lore, and a fun story driven video game experience to live through. I would have just appreciated my emotions being tugged on a bit more, but thanks to how some of the new characters just never felt like a sacred cow like Clem, I could have cared less what happened to them. Hell, I felt like most got what they deserved based on how they acted, so I didn’t feel any emotional pain at all, which was disappointing.

You should still play the episode if you’ve invested into the previous four, because From the Gallows is still a 75/100 type of gaming experience. It just never reaches you on an emotional level like Telltale games have done in the past, so its final felt a bit too blah.

Thanks for watching, Matt Heywood here signing off for, where we make you a better geek, one post at a time.


From the Gallows Review Summary

Story - 7
Gameplay - 7
Graphics - 8
Sound - 7.5
Entertainment Value - 8



From the Gallows isn't the best finale Telltale has ever cooked up, but it presents enough tough choices to keep you engaged. Plus, it definitely alludes to more series to come from Telltale, which is never a bad thing.

Buy the full Season


“Making you a better geek, one post at a time!”

Review Statement: The author of this review was provided an Xbox One code by the publisher for the purposes of this review.

Tags : The Walking Dead: A New Frontier
Matt Heywood

The author Matt Heywood

Matt Heywood is the founder and EIC of where he strives to make you a better geek, one post at a time! When he’s not scouring the Internet for interesting nuggets of awesomeness he can be found in his secret lair enjoying the latest and greatest video games, taking pictures of toys, or talking Star Wars on EB’s Star Wars Time podcast show.